The Fall Rally In Energy Prices Officially Ended Thursday After Huge Reversal In Morning Trade
The fall rally in energy prices officially ended Thursday after a huge reversal in morning trade wiped out 7 cent gains for refined products, leading to more heavy selling the afternoon. The complex is attempting to find a bottom this morning with modest gains, but the trend lines were broken this week, and the charts continue to favor lower prices in the weeks ahead.
In addition to the bearish technical outlook, the big physical players seem to be figuratively buying this selloff and literally not buying it as basis values in most US cash markets dropped for a 2nd straight day, adding to the severe losses in futures.
If you buy gasoline in the North East, you’re probably wondering why your prices went up yesterday even when RBOB dropped a nickel. Ethanol is the culprit as the price spike went completely off the rails yesterday, with values in the NYH area surging more than 50 cents on the day, after already jumping more than 40 cents this week. That jump in prices was enough to override the drop in gasoline, despite the 90/10 ratio between the two components. The forward curve chart below shows how incredibly steep the backwardation has become thanks to increased production, and a profound inability to transport that product, with $1/gallon separating prices in Chicago over just a few months, and New York values are nearly $1 more expensive than that today.
OPEC & Friends made no changes to their current output agreement Thursday, and will meet again in the month. This lack of change was credited with both yesterday’s price pullback, and the rally overnight, which tells you how much those headlines are worth. While the White House wasted no time in expressing their discontent with the cartel’s decision to only add 400,000 barrels/day of oil every month to global supplies, the Saudi Energy Minister clearly seemed to be growing weary of the criticism: “Oil is not the problem,” Saudi Energy Minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman told reporters. “The problem is the energy complex is going through havoc and hell.”
Another one bites the dust: Shell announced yet another refinery closure, with plans to shutter part of its German refining complex in the coming years, which would take roughly 150mb/day of capacity offline. P66 meanwhile announced it would begin repairs to its Belle Chasse facility that was swamped by Hurricane Ida, although it’s still not clear whether or not that plant will ever operate as a refinery again.
US payrolls increased by 531k in October, and the previous two months estimates were revised sharply higher in today’s jobs report, knocking both the official (U3) and real (U6) unemployment rates down a couple of tenths. Equity markets and the US Dollar jumped following the report which was stronger than most predicted, and energy futures seemed to not care much. This report could be another double edged sword however as the FED has made it clear this week that they’re looking for stronger employment as a signal before raising rates next year.
Click here to download a PDF of today's TACenergy Market Talk.
News & Views
View All
Energy Contracts Are Trying To Find A Floor After Taking Their Largest Weekly Losses Of The Year So Far Last Week
Energy contracts are trying to find a floor after taking their largest weekly losses of the year so far last week.
There’s not much in the way of news yet this morning, so the modest buying is largely being blamed on reports that Saudi Arabia raised its prices for Asian and Mediterranean buyers in June, signaling that demand is strong enough in those markets to shoulder the increase.
RBOB gasoline futures have already dropped 28 cents from the high set April 12th, leading the argument that prices have peaked for the season. The 200-day moving average comes in just under $2.50/gallon this week, some 6.5 cents below current values, and helps set a pivotal chart support layer. If prices break there, there’s a strong case that we’ll see another 20-30 cents of downside, similar to what we saw this time last year.
Money managers continued to reduce their net length in NYMEX contracts last week, as WTI, RBOB and ULSD saw a net decrease of more than 17,000 contracts of speculative length. The hedge fund liquidation seems to have run its course for this latest news cycle however, as new short positions accounted for the majority of the decrease, and WTI and Brent both saw new length added by the big speculators. Money managers are now net-short on ULSD, which could be another reason to think the bottom is near if you subscribe to the theory that the bandwagon-jumping hedge funds usually are wrong.
Baker Hughes reported a decline of 7 oil rigs and 3 natural gas rigs last week, bringing the combined total rig count to its lowest level in more than 2 years. Perhaps most noteworthy in this week’s report was that Alaska saw 5 of its 14 active rigs taken offline in just 1 week. It’s not yet clear if this may have anything to do with the startup of the transmountain pipeline which will have Western Canadian crude now competing more directly with Alaskan grades.
Click here to download a PDF of today's TACenergy Market Talk.
Energy Markets Are Pointing Modestly Higher To Start Friday’s Session
Energy markets are pointing modestly higher to start Friday’s session, in a meager attempt at a recovery rally at the end of what would be the worst week in over two months if prices settle near current values. The liquidation of speculative bets placed on higher energy prices ahead of the direct conflict between Israel and Iran continues to appear to be the driver of the weakness, and we’ll have to wait and see if this modest bounce is a sign that the liquidation is over, or just a pause before it picks up again. Most contracts remain in a precarious technical position with the potential for a slide towards $70 for WTI and $2.20 for both refined products if the buyers don’t get serious soon.
Stocks are pointing sharply higher after a slowdown in job growth reported in the April Non-Farm payroll report. The BLS reported an increase of 175,000 jobs for the month, down sharply from the 315,000 jobs added in March, and the February & March estimates were revised down a combined 22,000. Both the “official” (U-3) and “real” (U-6) unemployment rates ticked up by .1% to 3.9% and 7.4% respectively. The immediate positive reaction to negative news suggest that the bad news is good news low-interest-rate junkies believe this may help the FED’s dilemma of the US economy being too strong to cut rates. The big jump in equities has not seemed to spill over into energy contracts yet, as crude and refined product contracts changed very little following the report.
San Francisco diesel basis spiked 15 cents Thursday to reach the highest level of any market in the country so far this year at 35 cents over prompt futures. While there aren’t yet any refinery upsets reported to blame the spike on, PBF is undergoing planned maintenance at its Martinez facility, and of course P66 just finished converting its Rodeo plant to RD after Marathon converted its Martinez facility in the past couple of years, meaning there are at most only 2 out of the previous 5 refineries in the region operating near capacity these days. The question now is how quickly barrels can shift north from Southern California which continues to show signs of a supply glut with weak basis values and spot to rack spreads.
PBF continued the trend of Q1 refinery earnings that were sharply lower, but still healthy by longer-term historical standards. The company noted that its Saint Bernard (the parish, not the dog) Renewables facility co-processing at its Chalmette refinery had received provisional approval from CARB to lower its CI scores and help improve the amount of LCFS subsidies it can receive. That facility is operating at 18mb/day which is roughly 86% of its capacity.
Cenovus highlighted the restart of its Toledo and Superior refineries in improved refinery run rates in Q1 2024 vs Q1 2023 and noted that it had ramped up production at units that were slowed down for economic reasons in December and January (you may remember this as the time when midcontinent basis values were trading 50 cents/gallon below futures). The company did note that the January deep freeze slowed operations at Superior, but did not mention any change in operating rates despite numerous upsets at its 50% owned Borger refinery.
Dress rehearsal for a busy hurricane season? So far there are no reports of refinery issues caused by the flooding in the Houston area this week. At this point, most of the flooding appears to be far to the north of the refining hubs on the Gulf Coast but with more storms in the forecast and 88 counties already declaring disaster status, this will be something to watch for the next few days.
Click here to download a PDF of today's TACenergy Market Talk.
Crude Oil Inventories Climbed Above Year-Ago Levels For The First Time In 2024
Sell by May then go away.
The old trading adage looked good for energy markets in 2024 as the new month started off with the biggest daily sell-off of the year so far. WTI and ULSD contracts are now in “rally or else” mode on the charts with sharply lower prices a strong possibility now that technical support layers have broken down. RBOB doesn’t look quite as bearish on the charts, but seasonal factors will now act as a headwind as we’re well into the spring peaking window for gasoline prices, and we’ve already seen a 27 cent drop from the highs. If RBOB can hold above $2.50 there’s a chance to avoid a larger selloff, but if not, a run towards $2.20 for both gasoline and diesel looks likely in the months ahead.
The selling picked up steam following the DOE’s weekly report Wednesday, even though the inventory changes were fairly small. Crude oil inventories continue their steady build and climbed above year-ago levels for the first time in 2024. Demand for refined products remains sluggish, even after accounting for the RD consumption that’s still not in the weekly reports, and most PADDs are following a typical seasonal inventory trend. The Gulf Coast saw a healthy build in diesel inventories last week as the export market slowed for a 3rd straight week. Refinery runs dipped modestly last week following a handful of upsets across the country, but overall rates remain near normal levels for this time of year.
The Transmountain pipeline expansion began operations yesterday, completing a 12-year saga that has the potential to materially change refining economics for plants in the US that relied heavily on discounted Canadian crude to turn profits over the past decade.
The P66 Borger refinery reported another operational upset Monday that lasted a full 24 hours impacting a sulfur recovery unit. Last week the company highlighted how the plant’s fire department helped the surrounding area when the largest wildfire in state history came within feet of the facility.
The EPA approved a new model to determine life cycle carbon intensity scores this week, which cracks open the door for things like ethanol to SAF, which were previously deemed to not reduce emissions enough to qualify for government subsidies. The new model would require improved farming techniques like no-till, cover crop planting and using higher efficiency nitrogen fertilizer to limit the damage done by farms that no longer rotate crops due to the ethanol mandates. Whether or not the theoretical ability to produce SAF comes to fruition in the coming years thanks to the increased tax credit potential will be a key pivot point for some markets that find themselves with too much RD today, but could see those supplies transition to aviation demand.
The FED continues to throw cold water on anyone hoping for a near term cut in interest rates. The FOMC held rates steady as expected Wednesday, but also highlighted the struggles with stubbornly high inflation. The CME’s Fedwatch tool gave 58% odds of at least one rate cut by September before the announcement, and those odds have slipped modestly to 54% this morning.